Turns out I'll be going as a birthday present.
"Silent Treatment"... I've never really liked that song, even though I really like most of DYWM. I think it's the awful singing. The one song I think really sucks is "Hypnotic" (the bass line, ugh) on IH. I even bought the Men in Black OST 2nd-hand to get "The 'Notic", which is the infinitely superior version.
I'm relatively happy with the turn the last two albums have taken, though I could see them becoming a band in search of a purpose... (maybe others already believe this to be the case?)