Page 1 of 32 12311 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 471

Thread: How England Sees Itself

  1. #1
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    berlin
    Posts
    8,453

    Default How England Sees Itself

    did you all see this article? - Let's end the myths of Britain's imperial past

    i hope the Dissensus response will not be like the one to Black Athena: "everyone knows this already", ("everyone" must meaning blogger friends because there is only too much evidence in the real world to the contrary), like the first commenter on the article:

    "Where on earth is this cosy consensus that the British Empire was a good thing? Please, Richard, point to some examples of textbooks currently used in schools and recent television programmes that enforce an uncomplicated belief in the greatness of the Empire.

    I thought we were at least at post-post-revisionist history of this by now? Or did this article fall through from 1950 when the assumption of imperial superiority was fairly widespread?
    it seems to me that taking pride in colonialist history is something for sure a TAD more popular and mainstream in England compared to Germany (not sure about Belgium or France or Spain or Portugal), with ignorance levels of its own violent history rivaling the United States. and one can see this clearly judging only by the comments, a fair portion of which are along the lines of "Colonialism was both good AND bad", "It was natural/Inevitable", "Other empires were worse", or a number of things like:

    "What a load of whining leftie twaddle.

    The world was, of course, a very different place a century or two ago. Applying current perspectives to almost anything from that age may result in the feeble-minded reaching for the human rights act and saying how nasty it all was. No shit, sherlock! The alternatives may not have been any less palatable, free or peaceful.

    Proper history remains largely untaught in my children's schools - replaced by this kind of guilt-ridden thematic nonsense."
    how exactly would you characterize contemporary Britain's relationship to something like the 30 million Indian deaths due to starvation because of British self serving agricultural policies? or similar things in Ireland? or these kinds of control and repressive mechanisms in general, largely invented by the English?

    while the world still largely goes on endlessly about the Evil Germans, England seems to have gotten off much more easily. (comparisons are largely meaningless and futile, but just for perspective, of course the Nazis killed 6 million jews).

    have you all read this?



    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Late-Victori.../dp/1859847390
    Last edited by zhao; 31-10-2011 at 10:36 AM.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    14,998

    Default

    Hmm, it's difficult to say. I'm sure there are both crusty old conservatives and a younger generation of unpleasant nationalists (EDL etc.) who get misty-eyed and nostalgic about the Empire. It's pretty much de rigeur for left-wing or liberal white Brits to feel a good deal of guilt about the whole thing. Not sure how non-whites living here feel about it to be honest, and I'm sure there isn't a consensus non-white post-colonial attitude. I mean, India/Pakistan/Bangladesh/Sri Lanka were obviously under the imperial heel for a long time, but the people there weren't slaves (in the strict sense) and they weren't brought there from another continent, as the ancestors of black West Indians were, as well as black Americans of course.

    You're right that as far as 20th-century history goes, Britain makes much of having been on the side of Good against Nazi Germany, which did basically the Worst Thing Ever. But remember that the death toll of WWII went far beyond the Jews killed in the Holocaust (whose total toll was not six but eleven million). A total figure of 50 million is the usual estimate for the whole war. Then there's Japanese attrocities, which I know you're well aware of, and various Soviet abominations, which went on for a lot longer than those of the Nazis - by some estimates, Ukranian victims of the Holomodor outnumber Jewish victims of the Shoah, yet that unimaginable crime goes largely unnoticed in Western historiography.

    Also, don't confuse England with Britain. Many of the most important figures in the UK's imperial history were Scottish, Irish or Welsh.

    Interesting thread though, only just seen it.
    Last edited by Mr. Tea; 11-11-2011 at 07:44 PM.
    Doin' the Lambeth Warp New: DISSENSUS - THE NOVEL - PM me your email address and I'll add you

  3. #3
    droid Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Tea View Post
    You're right that as far as 20th-century history goes, Britain makes much of having been on the side of Good against Nazi Germany, who did basically the Worst Thing Ever.
    Mark Curtis estimates that approximately ten million deaths throughout the world since 1945 have been caused by the United Kingdom’s foreign policy.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Cu...British_author)

  4. #4

    Default

    Oh aye, and how did he calculate that exactly?

  5. #5
    droid Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by craner View Post
    Oh aye, and how did he calculate that exactly?
    Nice reflex.

    Direct and indirect deaths through examination of declassified state documents and various other sources afaik.

    How would you calculate it?

  6. #6

    Default

    Direct and indirect deaths through examination of declassified state documents and various other sources afaik.
    Eh?

  7. #7

    Default

    What I mean is, I presume he has a break down of this carnage? As in, this many died because of British action in the Falklands, this many died because of British action in the first Gulf War, and so on.

  8. #8
    droid Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by craner View Post
    What I mean is, I presume he has a break down of this carnage? As in, this many died because of British action in the Falklands, this many died because of British action in the first Gulf War, and so on.
    Sorry. Yes he does. In web of deceit and unpeople I think. Its been a while.

    http://markcurtis.info/

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    14,998

    Default

    Well I was talking more about Britain's self-image (as per thread title) rather than historic reality.
    Last edited by Mr. Tea; 11-11-2011 at 03:40 PM.
    Doin' the Lambeth Warp New: DISSENSUS - THE NOVEL - PM me your email address and I'll add you

  10. #10
    droid Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Tea View Post
    Well I was talking more about Britain's self-image (as per thread title) rather than historic reality.
    Yeah, of course, but that self-image seems to be predicated on ignorance or obscured by nationalism and PR. The problem is that Britain (like the US) has never been defeated and forced to face up to its past in the same way that other states have.


  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    14,998

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by droid View Post
    The problem is that Britain (like the US) has never been defeated and forced to face up to its past in the same way that other states have.
    Hmm, that's a good point. OTOH, Japan suffered a huge defeat in living memory and while there have been some public apologies from Japanese PMs (Emporers too? not sure), there's nothing like the 'remorse industry' that Germany's had for the last 60+ years.

    At least, that's my (admittedly scanty) understanding of it. Anyone here know much about post-war Japan?
    Doin' the Lambeth Warp New: DISSENSUS - THE NOVEL - PM me your email address and I'll add you

  12. #12
    droid Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Tea View Post
    Hmm, that's a good point. OTOH, Japan suffered a huge defeat in living memory and while there have been some public apologies from Japanese PMs (Emporers too? not sure), there's nothing like the 'remorse industry' that Germany's had for the last 60+ years.

    At least, that's my (admittedly scanty) understanding of it. Anyone here know much about post-war Japan?
    The Japanese have been resolutely pacifistic for decades. There are internal pressures and extreme nationalists of course, but they've resisted many opportunities to militarise despite the genuine threat of North Korean, Russian and Chinese aggression and expansion in the region.

    Whether things will stay that way in the future as the US position in SE asia deteriorates is another question.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    350

    Default

    in the 3rd part of adam curtis' series the living dead you can get quite an insightful look into the minds of thatcher and churchill and how they filtered out the naughty bits of britain's history to spread the image that you're talking about. highly recommended.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    14,998

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by droid View Post
    The Japanese have been resolutely pacifistic for decades. There are internal pressures and extreme nationalists of course, but they've resisted many opportunities to militarise despite the genuine threat of North Korean, Russian and Chinese aggression and expansion in the region.

    Whether things will stay that way in the future as the US position in SE asia deteriorates is another question.
    Sure, I'm not contesting any of that - I'm talking specifically about formal apologies and reparations to victims of attrocities committed before and during WWII which, by any measure, fall far short of those made by Germany. In Germany only a small minority of card-carrying neo-Nazis is anything but contrite about the war and the camps (at least, in public...), and it's illegal to display the swastika or other Nazi symbolism even in a history textbook. But apologies by Japanese leaders have provoked widespread nationalist backlashes of the kind unthinkable in Germany. They've even had highschool textbooks that downplay various attrocities.

    Edit: doesn't surprise me in the least that British conservatives have done much the same thing. Think things were a bit different by the time I was at high school, though.
    Last edited by Mr. Tea; 11-11-2011 at 05:35 PM.
    Doin' the Lambeth Warp New: DISSENSUS - THE NOVEL - PM me your email address and I'll add you

  15. #15
    droid Guest

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •