As Corpsey says though it's interesting that something a step removed such as Hyperdub receives fawning critical praise and attention while the real thing remains sidelined and maligned. Instead of recognising and celebrating what's going on people hate on the style of dancing or focus on abuse of laughing gas. Ultimately it's all a power struggle imo with labels such as Hyperdub easier for the established blogs and writers to exploit. The actual underground won't take being misrepresented or having to pretend and is too malleable to be pinned down by the average hack.
Answering to your post Continuum but to everyone on this thread really.
I'd ask: what's the bigger "problem" here, labels like Hyperdub actually releasing UK funky artists and widening their audiences or all the many labels we cant name because they didn't support it?
This feels like a very negative take on someone's pro-active response to interesting music.
Equally, people complain about Fact etc, but isn't the actual enemy the mainstream music institutions like commercial pop TV brands, big bland YouTube channels, dull daytime radio play list stations like Kiss or Heart, rockist publications like Q or Rolling Stone. That's the enemy, yo, not people who do or don't cover the lighter or darker shades of London's underground. How often do you think those guys rep for the creative underground?
The alt/dark v road/vocal/pop split is a contrived split too, both main scenes in this lineage (garage/2step through UK funky) at their peaks were compelling because they held in dynamic tension the light and the dark, the vocal and the dub, the song and the instrumental, the ruff and the smooth - often even in one track! If you're looking just at UKG or UKF you can't say it was just one side.
Now of course many people have subjective personal preferences - myself included - to one side or the other here, but that's fine: I still think if you asked all the London underground artists who got international bookings through hyperdub/tectonic/night slugs etc associations & exposure and compared them all to those who's careers died with the scene, I'm sure you'd get a clear picture.