sus
Moderator
I think the ambiguity's gotta lean toward Garfield being the dog killer. The Homeless King seems to have principles—Garfield on the other hand... When we're introduced to him, he's a selfish, shallow, unemployed voyeur. Sure, he proceeds put the charm on for his FWB when she comes by, but that should make us trust him less, not more.Some people think the Homeless King is the dog killer because he gets angry when he sees the dog biscuits, but then that could also be because he thinks Garfield's the dog killer.
And there's something a little off about him, right? Even beyond the biscuits. The strange, violent dreams. Parts of the record of events is missing—he just ends up naked at home after the reservoir, with a big blank space in between. He's not exactly a reliable narrator. Schizophrenia an active possibility—it's a bit like Zodiac or other films, where you can't tell if what he's onto is real or not.