The Natural State

entertainment

Well-known member
it's like people who go to Rio and expect it to be this magic land with bossa nova in the air, sensual bodies all singing and laughing, grilling chicken for each other on the street, drinking beers and playing cards

and then are appalled by the trashy streets, extravagant flashing of wealth and ubiquitous western fast food places
 

WashYourHands

Cat Malogen
Processed foods, information overload, misalignment of sense ratios...

If you have kids, the factual horror that these are among their inheritances remains grotesque.

Trying to source ethically produced foods, limiting their internet time and grounding them in as many visits out into the wilds as possible is what I try and sustain as a Dad. Camping, purifying water sources, cooking basic meals. All sounds a bit veteran in the woods, I know, but they love it.

I’ve found my own hard earned balance. Kids can get enveloped in this synthetic abhorrence, so they need trustworthy guides. Britain is a spectacular island if you explore it fully. The answer, as always, is outside urban zones.
 

Mr. Tea

Let's Talk About Ceps
Trying to source ethically produced foods, limiting their internet time and grounding them in as many visits out into the wilds as possible is what I try and sustain as a Dad. Camping, purifying water sources, cooking basic meals. All sounds a bit veteran in the woods, I know, but they love it.
I'm hoping to get my lad into this sort of thing in a few years. Living within shouting distance of Dartmoor is a big plus.

He'd better enjoy looking for mushrooms or the little fucker might find himself up for adoption.
 

constant escape

winter withered, warm
How does the natural, here, relate to equilibrium? I'm imagining a sort of landscape with valleys and hills, wherein it takes work to get up over some hill to attain rest in some valley. And there may well alway be a lower valley.

Can this translate to the kind of natural state(s) talked about here? Might it not be a matter of dropping the flak and fluster, but a matter of working through some kind of ingrained noise? Working through it, as in a kind of meditative practice - but an active one, an observational one.
 

entertainment

Well-known member
well I didn't conceptualise 'the natural', I was just using it to identify this vague recurring theme in lifestyle trends
 

constant escape

winter withered, warm
If we are valuing the natural as a state of balance, perhaps there are a variety, even a hierarchy, of such states, and getting from one to the "next" higher one involves purposefully disrupting what may otherwise feel like perfect balance. Disrupting, as in, leaving the rest of the valley to "climb" some incline, exerting work and thus experiencing disequilibrium, in order to arrive at the "lower" valley, the better balance. And so on.
 

luka

Well-known member
If we are valuing the natural as a state of balance, perhaps there are a variety, even a hierarchy, of such states, and getting from one to the "next" higher one involves purposefully disrupting what may otherwise feel like perfect balance. Disrupting, as in, leaving the rest of the valley to "climb" some incline, exerting work and thus experiencing disequilibrium, in order to arrive at the "lower" valley, the better balance. And so on.

thats what we were talking about on Gus's Forking Paths thread
 

luka

Well-known member
i dont think its particularly relevant here as breathing carbon monoxide and particulate matter is difficult to spin as bootstrapping yourself to a higher state of consciousness

but having said that there are obvious and very good reasons why sensible people are reluctant to posit an ideal state as that idea contains a kernel of totalitarianism. that's why it's more usual these days to think of a multitiude of states which are predicated on different inputs and different orientations and different values
 

luka

Well-known member
the urban state of consciousness and sense of being is obviously different to the rural state of consciousness and sense of being. they think and speak very slowly in the countryside for example and they wear gumboots. what you can access and attain, the possibilities available to you depends on where you are.
 

version

Well-known member
Surely there's no such thing as 'unnatural'? Everything's made out of naturally occurring things. Our lifestyle isn't unnatural. It's like saying it's 'unnatural' for a chimp to use sticks and stones as tools. They've developed to the point where that's just what they do.
 

luka

Well-known member
it's more a question of largely legitimate concerns and anxieities about the detrimental impact of our environments and lifestyles and how those anxieities are being exploited to sell us stuff
 

constant escape

winter withered, warm
Well I'm generally opposed to defining words such that they have no application, but I do think @version is right. Can we just think of the unnatural as a function of the natural? The natural folded over onto itself, differentiating itself from its established character?
 

luka

Well-known member
well you can if you like but does it throw any light on this thread and the things entertainment was talking about?
 

luka

Well-known member
"It is a deep feature of the Chinese world-view that man should live in harmony with nature. Now, this belief, which is of course invented by man, brings into man's concept of nature the apparently unifying concept of a potentially stable and meaningful relation between man and nature that is the way of harmony. The ancient sages and poets made claims like this. And yet because man is not a natural part of nature, the very attempt to mend the break and return to a 'natural' way must reveal that the break is fundamental and cannot be reversed. That we can try to return to nature, or wish to do so, reveals that it cannot be done."

more from the JHP essay posted above
 
Top