The Language Thread

Eric

Mr Moraigero
But isn't grammar is ultimately an appeal to an imposed hierarchy/power structure - who says/controls what's "correct"? Answer: those who "know" i.e. those who have been taught the rules and have accepted them as valid and as something to police.

In this context, couldn't we just take this to mean `native speakers'? Depends what we mean by ``grammar'' I guess ... Anyway I don't know that, at least on this reading, we should understand the rules as `something to police,' but more like `something we intuitively already know.' Surely we wouldn't try to quote/paraphrase someone's speech by saying `He there is a problem that said,' for instance. Old news to everyone here?
 

Mr. Tea

Let's Talk About Ceps
Yeah, I think it's not the case that you have to be part of some kind of social elite to know how to talk properly - it's just a sign of making a little effort to use the language correctly when speaking or writing. When I see people write things like Banana's 50p/lb or I would of said that, but..., I dislike it just because it looks 'wrong'. It's just sloppy and careless, and it's not even like those are examples of really advanced grammar; I could have spotted what was wrong with them when I was about 8.
 
Top