Re: Reynolds, I don't have a problem with his 'borderline fetishism for modernism', I think one of the most progressive/liberation/powerful elements of art is it's ability to create wholly new worlds, brand new idea, to literally expand the limits of reality (the 303 acid house bassline didn't exist, then it did, that literally changed our human senses, we might hear another noise now and compare it to that sound). I think art should try to be original, I think when something isn't original that is a bad thing to be held against it and critiqued, even if there are other values apart from originality it can also be judged for. I love deep tech, I love the scene, I think the quality of music is off the charts, but surely you must admit that there is something lost compared to say, hardcore which had wicked music, a wicked scene, and literally was also the birth of not only a new type of music, but a whole new cultural formation?
Buuuuut that said, it's not like there is anything more original than deep tech ATM. It's not like the stuff which is being called experimental (all that new grime, 130 stuff) isn't actually just a pastiche of past forms of experimentalism. I think it's a shame there's not something genuinely popular, genuinely wicked, and genuinely revolutionary like hardcore and grime or whatever, but seeing as that's the case you'd have to be mad not to enjoy what's a massive explosion of energy creating volumes of powerful, wicked music.
Basically there is no one credible working in dance music media now lol. There has been no media response to deep tech, there was no media response to jackin, nobody clocked all the amazing Midlands/northern grime around 2009-20111, nobody clocked the evolution of bassline post Heartbroken into really dark, weird, MC driven, 2-steppy zones with DJ Pantha, UKB and all that.
The last scene of any import the media made any attempt to engage with was Funky. Otherwise 'UK rave music' the last 5 years in the media has come to mean "anything that evolved from Joy Orbison" and "token coverage of Wiley"
Edit: I also think what Reynolds did was make the very powerful argument for the place of things like hardcore, jungle, garage into a history of modernism/the avant guard, along with stuff like post-punk etc. His was a project of claiming for these working class/BME art forms the same respect as we give Joyce and Picasso or whatever, arguing that there's a whole tradition of popular modernism that the official account leaves out. In as far as this is true and he's contributed to a more inclusive, more accurate cultural history, he's done the world a great service. In as far as we're probably only 5-10 years away for a V&A exhibition on garage fashion and Goldie doing adverts for butter, it was probably a total calamity in hindsight lol