we have a keith jarrett thread so.......
i only have a few bits
dave holland
julian priester
marion brown
(all very early)
and always have written off 99% of the output as slick crap
but
are there nice things beyond those records?
i heard a really nice eberhard weber record once....
Provocative opening post and very cool thread but I must confess that I have a hard time with the "too slick" and (later in the thread) "too new agey" criticisms. I mean, yeah, of course, the unified aesthetic of packaging and production are completely obvious and easy objections, but they were equally so already twenty years ago, in the mid-80s, when I first began buying ECM records. Maybe it's just a critical taste kind of thing, but criticizing ECM on this basis feels a little bit like complaining that the sun is bright. I mean, it is what it is, and what it 'is' happens to be pretty much exactly what the guy set out to do: he had a vision and brought it to fruition in a very big way - that kind of commitment and ability to alter the industry landscape are not insignificant.
Regarding the ECM New imprint alone, to have published recordings by John Adams, Gyorgy, Kurtág, Alfred Schnittke, Heinz Holliger, Steve Reich and Arvo Pärt at the same time that you are doing major jazz and ambient jazz fusion-y releases is no mean feat, no matter what you think of the composers themselves (can't stand Part's music, personally).
In the mid-80s there was trad jazz and a huge spate of fusion-heavy music around, and ECM managed to create a little weirdo niche in between. There were clunkers but plenty of gems. You might get a beguiling John Abercrombie record or a weird synth-pop thing with L Shankar and his wife Caroline (The Epidemics). To take but one other example, Pat Metheny's first record was stunning and a very important introduction of a young artist to the jazz scene - though I'm sure that dissensians will heap loathing on him, I'll argue the merits of early Metheny with anyone, no reservations.
Major points to Eicher for his work with Godard, too.