I'm sure third will excoriate me for saying that though
Disagree with you on them being against pastiche or for saying they nail the simulation? Not sure that’s so
@thirdform cos hes not even keen on the sultry rnb amen heavy ragga tinged stuff, and this approximates it pretty accurately. I like the bit at 1:41 in “Outta Mind” but while both ‘bang’ they’re just really safe. And the dub siren and chat samples are cliché and repetitive. Even in ‘94 these would be good records but a little on the boring side.
Let’s sample a Dua Lipa vocal or some Top 40 instrumental snippet, throw in some humor, a wacky drum element that ‘works’ with more traditional breaks, stick your neck out a bit more with the rhythm programming, pump fake the retro sound and ridicule it with calculated risk taking, and be more synthetic/eclectic if you’re gonna ape the past. We’ve brought up Phineus before and sure he’s guilty too (ancient technology, well-worn pads, etc) but he does get weirder than a lot of his contemporaries in his drum programming I think. We don’t have to be groundbreaking or get unrecognizably difficult to listen to to escape the problem you’re describing IMO i guess people just don’t see the point in trying, if it aint (subjectively) broke don’t fix it