That's a good version but I can't agree. Here is the definitive version.
The minimalist arrangement of just guitar and those exquisite strings, plus Bobbie's cracked voice capture the small town drama of the story better I reckon.
The thing that kills me about this song is how she's sitting there biting her tongue at the kitchen table listening to her parents talk so blithely about her dead boyfriend - "Never had a lick of sense. Pass the biscuits."
And wtf did they throw off the bridge? Was it their baby?