Craner Explains What Happens Next

luka

luka

Well-known member
Craner What Would You Do if you were in charge? would you smash Putin's face in or would you do sanctions or what would be your course of action here?
 
luka

luka

Well-known member
i wish id known that when i was in the playground. or maybe i just doubted my face-smashing abilities.
 
craner

craner

Beast of Burden
luka said:
how will he go? who will move against him? will be get to retire peacefully with his nest egg or will be come to a stickier end?
Click to expand...

I have no idea, but if he actually had launched a massive invasion and occupation I can't see that ending well for him at all, but I've never been very convinced that's what he would do. But he's the master of ambiguity, like you, so nobody really knows what he's going to do. Therefore I'd just smash his face in and get it over with.
 
craner

craner

Beast of Burden
This is what Cristina Odone's long-suffering husband reckons and he is the man who diagnosed the New Cold War back in 2008:


Which basically translates as, "he's fucking infuriating, smash his face in!"
 
craner

craner

Beast of Burden
luka said:
is he the leninology blog that makes steam come out of your ears?
Click to expand...

Yes, sorry, I deleted it by accident.

What should the Left outside Ukraine say about this? What can we do, if anything, by way of solidarity? The Stop the War Coalition has issued a statement, which concentrates its fire on NATO expansionism, neo-Cold War rhetoric by Western politicians, and the proposed deployment of UK troops to Russia's border. It calls for the UK to support "serious diplomatic proposals" which recognise both Ukrainian integrity and Russian security concerns. To this extent, it focuses on what the Left in the UK can actually affect. And if it avoids saying a single critical word about what Russia is doing, I would infer that's largely because it doesn't want to expend a single cent of political capital on giving comfort to the West's warmongers. After all, there is a history of leftists collapsing, through shades and degrees of intellectual dereliction, into liberal imperialism. I get it. And, up to a point, I accept its priorities for mobilisation.

However, while it's up to Stop the War how they calculate their interventions, it would be a serious mistake for the Left to be uncritical, or mealy-mouthed, about what Russia is doing. Russia shouldn't be demonised, but it is not a victim here. It may not be the global threat to peace that NATO is, but is a major source of peril in this situation. It may have 'security concerns' like any other state, but it also a continental imperialist power and a great deal of bloody mayhem has been justified by those 'concerns'. The Left didn't hesitate to oppose the murder in Chechnya, and I think we have to be on our guard that it could happen again, even if it's averted in the short-term. What if we find ourselves protesting, 'Hands off Ukraine', having not clearly explained beforehand that we opposed what Russia was doing?

In general, I take the view, which not everyone supports, that the US is a declining power. This means I think we have to grapple with the challenges posed by rising regional powers, like Russia and China. We have to think critically about the kinds of economic, political and cultural reach they have beyond military intervention, and how that relates to their different conceptions of political order. Russia's alliance with the European far-right, for example, is a problem that is congruent with its domestic political priorities and its approach to global order. Which means that Russian chauvinism 'over there' is also a problem 'over here'. If we don't engage with that, then obviously we leave our own side intellectually disarmed, and we leave the job of formulating important political realities to our opponents. We cede the monopoly over certain truths to those who want to weaponise them. There's a real danger in that.
Click to expand...

 
craner

craner

Beast of Burden
Keep in mind, some people on his side recycle the Kremlin "genocide in Donbas" line without amendment, so in that context his piece is good.
 
craner

craner

Beast of Burden
luka said:
i do find it weird how people are so self important they feel they need to come up with a 'position' on world events lol
Click to expand...

It's true, I was thinking the same thing when I was posting it, why am I posting him as if he's important in any way?

But then, I get gripped watching how the self-declared anti-imperialist left contort themselves in the face of these events.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Tea

Mr. Tea

Let's Talk About Ceps
luka said:
i do find it weird how people are so self important they feel they need to come up with a 'position' on world events lol
Click to expand...
It'd be pretty dull if we restricted conversation to things that directly impact only ourselves, or only this country, though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top