That's not what you just said.zhao said:no. ancient rhythm traditions not only survive but thrive not BECAUSE of, but IN SPITE OF, oppression.
But I think you are missing the point there. I'm saying that your idea of what caused what, where things come from, is reductive and linear - just as it would be if someone were to say that techno was invented by Kraftwerk. We all know that there are large helpings of gospel, soul, funk, disco in house music, including detroit, but there are also all sorts of other things too, just as there are in those earlier traditions.the impulse to SHAKE your booty did not come from Japanese Keyboard manufacturers, and it did not come from the precision engineering of the Swiss.
it came from the abject POVERTY of the ghettos, it came from poor black people finding hope where there is no hope, it came from jazz, it came from gospel, it came from the pissed on and the forgotten: the African American experience.
Also I think when people say things like that Detroit techno guys were influenced by European synth music they really don't usually mean that at the exclusion of all those other elements. It's usually meant as an interesting factor in addition to the other obvious antecedents. And that mix is partly what makes it Detroit techno.
One love, one people innit. Stop all the reductive nonsense.