IdleRich
IdleRich
Haven't seen a thread about this but it's quite a weird/interesting development that seems to have kicked up a storm and pissed off a lot of people. Unsurprisingly as most of these professors seem to be or claim to be on the left but look as though they are going to make some money from ushering in a system of paying for education.
For those who haven't seen:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2011/jun/05/new-university-college-humanities-degrees
There seem to be a number of controversies above and beyond the fact that it could be the start of a two-tier education system. Off the top of my head:
1. You get a University of London degree that you can get elsewhere for half the price.
2. They claim to be offering scholarships for the disadvantaged but this seems to be predicated on the idea that the government will give grants up to the first £9k whereas the government say that they won't give any grants to students at universities that charge above the £9k cap.
3. Some of the "star" lecturers are only going to teach for one hour in the first year.
4. The course descriptions for their courses have been copied off the websites of a number of other institutions which are accredited by University of London.
I'm sure there are more things... any thoughts?
For those who haven't seen:
A new private university in London staffed by some of the world's most famous academics is to offer degrees in the humanities, economics and law from 2012 at a cost of £18,000 a year, double the normal rate.
The Oxbridge-style university college aims to educate a new British elite with compulsory teaching in science literacy, critical thinking, ethics and professional skills on top of degree subjects taught in one-to-one tutorials.
Its first master will be the philosopher AC Grayling, and top teachers from Harvard, Princeton, Oxford and Cambridge will include Richard Dawkins teaching evolutionary biology and science literacy, Niall Ferguson teaching economics and economic history and Steven Pinker teaching philosophy and psychology.
New College of the Humanities, based in Bloomsbury, is being backed by private funding and will aim to make a profit. It will offer some scholarships, with assisted places being granted to one in five of the first 200 students.
Grayling said he was motivated in part by fears that government cuts to university humanities and arts courses could leave "the fabric of society poorer as a result".
"Society needs us to be thoughtful voters, good neighbours, loving parents and responsible citizens," he said. "If we are to discover and inspire the next generation of lawyers, journalists, financiers, politicians, civil servants, writers, artists and teachers, we need to educate to the highest standards and with imagination, breadth and depth."
The college aims to attract candidates with at least three A grades at A-level with the promise of more direct teaching than at traditional universities. The student-teacher ratio will be better than 10 to one and there will be 12 to 13 hours' contact with teachers each week.
Graduates will come away with a degree from the University of London and a separate diploma from the college to reflect the additional course that includes practical professional skills such as financial literacy, teamwork, presentation and strategy.
Other teachers signed up include Sir David Cannadine, a history lecturer at Princeton; Ronald Dworkin QC, a leading constitutional lawyer teaching at University College London and New York University; and Steve Jones, a leading geneticist. Lawrence Krauss, professor of Earth and space exploration and physics at Arizona state university, who has advised Barack Obama on science policy, will teach cosmology and science literacy.
One of the backers is Charles Watson, chairman of the City PR firm Financial Dynamics. He said: "Higher education in the UK must evolve if it is to offer the best quality experience for students and safeguard our future economic and intellectual wealth. New College offers a different model – one that brings additional, private sector funding into higher education in the humanities when it is most needed, and combines scholarships and tuition fees."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2011/jun/05/new-university-college-humanities-degrees
There seem to be a number of controversies above and beyond the fact that it could be the start of a two-tier education system. Off the top of my head:
1. You get a University of London degree that you can get elsewhere for half the price.
2. They claim to be offering scholarships for the disadvantaged but this seems to be predicated on the idea that the government will give grants up to the first £9k whereas the government say that they won't give any grants to students at universities that charge above the £9k cap.
3. Some of the "star" lecturers are only going to teach for one hour in the first year.
4. The course descriptions for their courses have been copied off the websites of a number of other institutions which are accredited by University of London.
I'm sure there are more things... any thoughts?