thanks PD. i'm going to give this thread a good read tomorrow. it's funny, a lot of your second tier ones would have been in my top list (cypress hill s/t, low end theory, one for all, ). and
36 chambers would be in my top 3 or 5. jb's
done by the forces of nature would be up there too. at the time i think it was overshadowed by nwa and de la's debuts, but the production and MCing have aged much better than either, i think.
good to see at least an honourable mention for the first x-clan album. that one doesn't really get its due. no kmd though? is
mr. hood too corny?
illmatic has always been a sore point for me. it's really good, but i was disappointed when it came out, and put off by what seemed to be a decision ahead of time at The Source and elsewhere to canonize it (5 'mics') before having heard it. nas was
going to deliver a 'classic', period. but i don't think anything on there touched the 'halftime' 12" or his verses on 'live at the bbq.' to me,
illmatic was when his head started to get big and he began to get lazy. it also came out at the same time as snoop's debut which had a similar buzz (and, likewise, i thought 'deep cover' was better than most of
doggystyle) but got 4.5 mics in the reviews. i'd take nas over snoop anytime but, in print, it read like a middle finger to the west coast from new york editors wanting to maintain their hegemony.
'step in the arena' would be on my list too. and barely anything after 1995 because i lost interest. i know i missed some things (timbaland, most notably) but dre, jay-z, biggie, etc. did nothing at all for me. oh and biggie smalls is the most overrated rapper ever

glad to see you didn't have him at the top.