Has there been any comment on the methodology of this, seeing as it's not a real number?
The number of deaths in the UK has moved from running at below long-term averages to well above them as a result of the pandemic. Excess deaths from all causes stand 16,952 above the seasonal average across the UK since fatalities from Covid-19, the disease caused by the virus, began to mount in mid-March.
The “all cause excess mortality” figure is widely recognised as the best measure of the death toll linked to the pandemic.
David Spiegelhalter, the Winton professor of public understanding of risk at Cambridge university, said it was “the only unbiased comparison” given the problems measuring deaths and their causes.
But because of the lag in collating the data, the ONS published figures for the period to April 10 are significantly out of date as they are based on registrations received by the statistical office, which on average arrive four days after the actual date of death.
The FT’s analysis has extrapolated these figures using the latest trends in the daily hospital deaths assuming the relationship between these and total excess deaths remained stable, as it has so far over the course of the pandemic.
Using this calculation, a conservative estimate of UK excess deaths by April 21 was 41,102.
Carl Henegan, professor of evidence based medicine at Oxford university, said the deadly effects of Covid-19 were much more marked than during a bad outbreak of seasonal influenza.
“I don’t think we’ve ever seen such a sharp upturn in deaths at that rate,” he said. The 2017-18 seasonal flu outbreak may have killed 50,000 in the UK but “the reason we did not get alarmed then was that they were spread out over many weeks”.
The ONS data also showed that deaths at home and in care homes had also jumped sharply during the pandemic. In the week ending April 10, deaths in care homes reached 4,927, almost double the figure of 2,471 a month earlier.
I've been tracking the weekly excess death rates given by the ONS and comparing them to official covid-19 deaths (because I know how to have a good time). In the weeks ending 27/03 and 3/04, the excess deaths (compared to the previous five years' average) was about twice the official covid-19 toll. The week after that (the most recent available) it was about 60% higher. Although that only takes us up to the very beginning of the current period where we're routinely seeing >700 official covid-19 deaths a day.
However, the general mortality rate this up until the pandemic hit was somewhat lower than the five-year average, presumably because the weather's been so mild (hence lower death toll from normal vanilla flu), so the FT may have taken that into account to get this (even) higher number.
Yes, I know you are convinced that 41,000 people have died, I was just asking if anybody had any comment on how accurate the number is or how useful the method used to reach it is. Unlike you, I'm not an experienced statistician, so it's hard to tell.
@craner - I'm not a statistician either but I have some grasp of the basic concept, and I can well believe that the true death toll is twice the official figure.
For one thing, they're not counting deaths outside of hospitals, and other Western European countries with a similar age profile to ours are reporting about half of all coronavirus deaths happening in care homes.
Im not convinced of anything and have made no indication that I was or wasn't.
However, the FT has been pretty reliable in its modelling and coverage, multiple media organisations have been relying on its analysis and although this estimate seems higher than the widely accepted figures of about +50% the methodology seems reasonable and its certainly within the realms of possibility, so barring the exposure of some major flaw in their method, I see no reason to disbelieve it.
LONDON (Reuters) - Restrictions on everyday life in Britain to slow the spread of COVID-19 are likely to be needed for the “next calendar year” due to the time needed to develop and roll out vaccines or find a cure, the country’s top medic said on Wednesday.
Well, I did, and I asked for it. I'm not really sure why you had to be such a dick about it.
Baffling. Nevermind.