I just don't see what everyone's so excited about with Autechre. I wish I could, tbh, cos people are frothing in the comments section. I don't think there's nothing there to admire, I'm sure there is but to my ears -
they've simply "evolved" from one form of banality to another. They don't sound radical to me, they sound old hat. They sound like the dictionary definition of WIRE music. Their bloodless, milky synths in a minor chord never change. Their habit of making every tune at least 5 minutes too long (or 15) never changes. Burrowing away at the same loop for 20 minutes, like somebody tonguing a rotten tooth. What's to like? It's lost on me.
I was never a fan of "live sets" by techno ppl either. Twiddling away on knobs for hours, theoretically fascinating.
Aphex is a genius IMO. These guys are plodders.
But that's just to my ears. Maybe it was all that public schooling I had at my comprehensive school?
lol. Thridform's unreasonable haranguing actually produced something good!
Im not even going to try and address criticism of their early work because its clearly insane, but wrt live/set WIRE music...
I find a lot of their post LP5 work challenging in the same way that I find Coltrane or modern classical challenging. Its music that demands a huge amount from the listener. As most of my listening is ambient (as in not wholly concentrated) listening it means I don't listen to them that much.
However, in a live setting they are amazing. Probably the best live electronic act of all time. Ive seen them play to a packed dance floor and create synergistic feedback loops with the audience based on the instant 5D manipulation of twisted fragments and shards of noise, rhythm and melody or (like at the NCH gig) scrawl these gargantuan phantasmographic soundscapes in the minds of the audience, like some multidimensional aural Pollock.
They are pioneers without peers. IMO theyre early work is certainly equal to anything Aphex did in his prime, but whereas James' has been content to explore more microtonal and instrumental variations on his themes since the early 00s, AE have gone into deep space.
Nobody else comes close.