Mr. Tea
Let's Talk About Ceps
Fair enough. That's pretty depressing.I said what I said
Fair enough. That's pretty depressing.I said what I said
The outright slaughter of civilian refugees, killed by American bullets fired from American guns by genocidal Israelis.
This illustrates a deep point: that people's stances do not represent their goals explicitly, they are locally-sensitive correctives aimed at implicit goals.All the art-world Jews I know were outspoken anti-Zionists before the conflict, and have been driven towards an Israel-sympathetic stance because of how rabidly, unquestioningly pro-Hamas their peers are.
All the corporate Jews I know were liberal Zionists before the conflict, and have been driven towards a Palestine-sympathetic stance because of how rabidly, unquestioning pro-Israel their peers are.
Since you are not in favour of Hamas surrendering, then you are for them continuing and presumably you want them to continue and win rather than lose...how is that not pro-Hamas?Fair enough. That's pretty depressing.
dude I don't give a shit winning points in a stupid internet debate club or pwning fuckwit trash like biscuits or whateverNormally I'm not a wagering man, but methinks Biscuits could singlehandedly keep this thread riled up for another 100 pages.
Both sides should stop fighting, but one side is causing nearly all of the death and destruction right now. A side you've consistently failed to condemn or criticise in any way, because you're objectively pro-genocide.Since you are not in favour of Hamas surrendering, then you are for them continuing and presumably you want them to continue and win rather than lose...how is that not pro-Hamas?
Firstly, I have criticised the Israelis, including floating the idea that October 7 was an inside job...something for which you had no enthusiasm, perhaps because it would take some of the shine away from Hamas!Both sides should stop fighting, but one side is causing nearly all of the death and destruction right now. A side you've consistently failed to condemn or criticise in any way, because you're objectively pro-genocide.
Yes, it's almost like beliefs and actions have consequences. Framing it as "mind contagion" is nonsense but classic gus, so there you go. Hundreds of people are dying every day and almost 2 million are displaced and starving. I cannot summon up much sympathy for people dealing with tense office atmospheres in their not being bombed, not under siege, stocked with food offices.I have successfully insulated myself from these sorts of mind contagions, but my peers report stifling atmospheres and entrenched lines of intra-office conflict. One lit mag, The Drift, committed social suicide early in the conflict, letting go of a Palestinian editor. (At a recent Cleveland Review of Books launch, the large number of RSVPs—200+—was partially attributed to this self-destructive act.) Anti-racist activists are boycotting Israeli- and Jewish-owned businesses. Non-profit boards across Manhattan are fighting proxy battles, taking out hits, pulling funding. Several long-term monogamous couples in my proximate social circles have recently embarked on breaks, citing irreconcilable differences of view.
You know damn well that I meant criticising Israel for killing Gazan civilians on a massive scale.Firstly, I have criticised the Israelis, including floating the idea that October 7 was an inside job...something for which you had no enthusiasm, perhaps because it would take some of the shine away from Hamas!
They are clearly not as good at this disambiguation trick as you are:Yes, it's almost like beliefs and actions have consequences. Framing it as "mind contagion" is nonsense but classic gus, so there you go. Hundreds of people are dying every day and almost 2 million are displaced and starving. I cannot summon up much sympathy for people dealing with tense office atmospheres in their not being bombed, not under siege, stocked with food offices.
The two most prominent boycotts of businesses - one in Canada, one in Philly - were linked to the owners materially supporting the IDF (via the Lone Soldier program) and/or firing employees for pro-Palestinian views. I invite anyone to turn up a single incident of a Jewish-owned business being targeted bc its Jewish-owned rather than some similar reason to those two examples.
All killing is wrongYou know damn well that I meant criticising Israel for killing Gazan civilians on a massive scale.
Concisely putThis illustrates a deep point: that people's stances do not represent their goals explicitly, they are locally-sensitive correctives aimed at implicit goals.
Lol literally people I know are doing this, I don't need to link to newspaper articlesI invite anyone to turn up a single incident of a Jewish-owned business being targeted bc its Jewish-owned rather than some similar reason to those two examples. (personally I don't think targeting small businesses is a very effective tactic, but that's a different issue)
Point taken. Don't want my peanut gallery comments to add to anyones stress here.dude I don't give a shit winning points in a stupid internet debate club or pwning fuckwit trash like biscuits or whatever
what I care about is thousands of people being killed by a far-right govt that is coopting part of my identity to justify that killing. secondarily I care about the poisonous effects of this war and the occupations on Israel, where for better or worse part of my family lives.
get some perspective, plz. these are real things that really happening. they are not just grist for an endless sea of meaningless banter and then we go to another thread and banter about movies or whatever.
Millions of people are under siege or starving in places that aren't Gaza, too. All the time. Every day. These people just happen to specifically fit into political narratives that we've attached our identities to, which is why we suddenly care.Yes, it's almost like beliefs and actions have consequences. Framing it as "mind contagion" is nonsense but classic gus, so there you go. Hundreds of people are dying every day and almost 2 million are displaced and starving. I cannot summon up much sympathy for people dealing with tense office atmospheres in their not being bombed, not under siege, stocked with food offices.
No you're right, I definitely didn't care about Chiapas or Rwanda or Iraq or Afghanistan or any other place where terrible things have happened. I famously never said anything about any of those places. And I definitely haven't been paying attention to Israel since my dad moved there in the 80s. I don't have blood relatives in the IDF who are part of this awful war. I don't have a friend who was maimed by the Israeli border police for covering a protest against the wall. You're definitely right, it just fits into my political narratives and I only began caring on Oct 7th.Millions of people are under siege or starving in places that aren't Gaza, too. All the time. Every day. These people just happen to specifically fit into political narratives that you've attached an identity to, which is why you suddenly care.
Padraig's hoping that if he posts enough, Tea will send some baggies of wavy cap psilocybes to the Palestinians, and Luka will write pro-Palestinian poetry on the Thames, and the siege will enddude I don't give a shit winning points in a stupid internet debate club or pwning fuckwit trash like biscuits or whatever
what I care about is thousands of people being killed by a far-right govt that is coopting part of my identity to justify that killing. secondarily I care about the poisonous effects of this war and the occupations on Israel, where for better or worse part of my family lives.
get some perspective, plz. these are real things that really happening. they are not just grist for an endless sea of meaningless banter and then we go to another thread and banter about movies or whatever.