Logan Sama said:No it isn't.
It is an accurate description of the demographic the music played by 1xtra and in so called "Urban" events appeals to. They predominantly live in the UK's densely populated Urban areas.
I double dog dare you to tell me Grime or Garage is "Black" music when there isn't a single black person who has a regular grime focussed show on legal radio.
Tactics said:this response isn't serious....is it? Logan what part of Africa did you live in if you don't mind me asking?
anyway in response to the other person asking for a black music thread...lets do it. The thread to end all threads!
almost forgot! My boy bought 'Industry Standard - The Trilogy' round my drum last night and cot damn...Terror's doen it again. It was a badly scratched vinyl (hi Uptown!) but man I thought you guys would've been talking about it nuff. That 'Stiff' track - words ain't enough. Does anyone realise that that's a d'n'b/jungle break he's using? The one with D.O.K - hypement. 'Radar' - nuff said. Anyone heard/copped it?
outraygeous said:terror is so advanced, hes like the xbox 360 of grime
next generation
gumdrops said:lol (im guessing/hoping that was meant to be a joke)
its not like all the millions of rock artists in the world have slavishly held on to what it sounded like in the hands of black musicians or keep its blues/R&B roots intact.
confucius said:1. fat chance.
2. but they have, more than not. Led Zepplin and Rolling Stones played wholesale black music. and I think most people consider that stuff to be the main bloodline of rock'n'roll.
face it, 20th Century popular forms of music, from jazz to rock to house to hiphop, it's ALL OF IT black.
mms said:notions of purity
confucius said:who said shit about purity??? ain't nothing pure.
mms said:you said all 20th century popuklar forms of music were black, which is silly.
confucius said:I said the roots of all 20th century western popular music is most definitely black.
anyone who refuses to acknowledge this is the real silly.
but I didn't say anything was "pure".
confucius said:face it, 20th Century popular forms of music (in the west atleast), from jazz to rock to house to hiphop, it's ALL OF IT black
MATT MAson said:I have to agree with Confucius. Nearly all forms of modern pop music have black roots. Even Kraftwerk - check their influences. But that doesn't mean everything that followed is 'black' music, anymore than modern languages should be considered simple extensions of Sanskrit. Modern music scenes are way more complex beasts, taking in myriad influences. Even hip hop, disco and house, all considered black music forms, were products of multicultural society created by pioneers of a number of different races.
confucius said:once and for all:
rock'n'roll is more black than anything else. because it comes from blues, r'n'b, gospel, and funk -- Afro American traditions. end of discussion.
Le Bob said:BUT, rock'n'roll did take ques from white country music to shape it into how we know it today.
Logan Sama said:I double dog dare you to tell me Grime or Garage is "Black" music when there isn't a single black person who has a regular grime focussed show on legal radio.