I thought that Antichrist was a bit of a dog's dinner to be honest. It did have some powerful scenes but too often bits that I think were supposed to be scary just had me lauhging and there is nothing that detracts as much from an atmosphere of horror as that. I wouldn't say that the film was terrible but for me there was just too much wrong with it for it to work as a whole.
But has anyone seen Prometheus yet?
i saw it last night. its neither a masterpiece, nor a disaster really, but it is really thin on plot and general substance, spends about an hour building background and atmosphere, which i liked, but it doesnt really take it anywhere that interesting. it has 1 or 2 great scenes, but if youve seen the older alien films, youve prob seen similar stuff.
my main prob was that it throws in a few lines about BIG themes here and there for profundity, but they arent taken far enough, and the whole story about them being on the planet to 'meet their makers' is seriously repetitive and didnt seem to add up to anything. but then its by the guy who wrote lost, which was all about padding a few interesting ideas out for years, and was never quite as deep and meaningful as people seemed to think, so what dyou expect. its also based on a pretty knackered franchise, so its basically just a lot of waffle in an attempt to link itself to the first alien film.
BUT it is a brilliant looking film. the sets are some of the best sci fi sets ive seen in a while. lots of brits in it too - fassbender is typically great. idris elba seems to be in a diff movie entirely, and idk if it was just me, but i couldnt figure out what he was saying half the time. his accent was just weird. starting to think that if hes not playing stringer bell, hes bound to be hammy.
the whole thing is just bizarre though - all that money and effort and they couldnt even come up with a better story. there must be someone writing better fan fiction about alien than this.
I know what you mean - I loved the bit with the faun and the stuff about the shoes on the wrong feet is really creepy.... but still, on balance it didn't add up for me."A dogs dinner, that is funny, is that a popular phrase in England? I don't know, I rate films almost entirely on their looks, their visual appearance and for me some of the scenes stood out so perfectly, it's like photography almost. The male protagonist standing under those trees with acorns falling on him in slow motion. The child falling down with the snowflakes going harder than himself. The pictures of a person dressed in white going through that dark forest. It's so stylised, I can hardly believe this film is done by someone from the Dogme manifest, this film is the complete opposite."
Read a summary of the plot and some of the stuff happening in it sounds completely ridiculous.Exactly this ^^^ except I liked Idris Elba and was much harsher about the plot when I came out. It's actually pro-creationist gibberish, and I expected more from Scott if not from that, that misinformation valve that wrote it. If you try and tie the plot together it completely falls apart, it's paltry.
misinformation valve
which makes me think that this might be one of those times when they could actually have done with more script doctors on board.